Josefina Rivera, Agnes Adams, Sandra Lindsay, Jacqueline Askins, Deborah Dudley, Lisa Thomas


There were six of them, chained in the basement of a Philadelphia house. The police almost couldn’t believe what they were seeing. The horrors of what the women experienced were almost unbearable to hear. Their kidnapper, Gary Heidnik, chained them, enslaved them, raped them, starved them, murdered two of them and forced them to eat another human being (feeding the rest of the body to the dogs).

What did all of these young women have in common? They were young, black and brown girls from the lower echelon of society. They grew up poor, some of them were prostitutes, all of them perceived to be “unwanted.” Our America, hosted by Lisa Ling on the Oprah Winfrey Network, featured the stories of missing Black women and the now infamous Heidnik kidnapping case. A quick google search of his name will render headlines like “Heidnik’s House of Horrors.”

Indeed the women survived an unimaginable, terrifying ordeal. One of the survivors, named Jackie shared her experiences. She now suffers from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and depression. Sometimes, she blacks out and unconsciously re-enacts being chained to the basement floor and eating dog food.

For months Jackie and 5 other women languished in a seemingly timeless agony, wondering if they would ever get their freedom.

When hearing about these types of stories, the blame is usually placed solely on the perpetrator. Yet, we need to realize that society plays a complacent role in allowing these types of crimes to occur. All too often perceived “respectability” trumps humanity. Lives are somehow worth less, or are less important if the victims did not lead “perfect” lives as dictated by societal norms. This is especially the case for young Black women, people living in poverty and for sex workers.

Jackie, being a symbol of this marginalized trifecta, was as they noted in the documentary, “lost before she was kidnapped.” As she lived on the margins of society, Heidnik presumed that no one would miss her. And for the most part he was right.

Jackie asked, “Did anybody care that we were out there? Just to call 911 and say, ‘she’s gone?’ Who cared about a Black prostitute, on drugs?”

So as four of the six women, survived until they were finally freed, time moved on without them. And as they finally regained their freedom, society gasped at the horrors they’d experienced, media focused on the perpetrator and in-depth discussions concerning why or how this truly could have happened in the first place, were passed over in the name of sensationalism.

Moreover, Jackie returned to a community that blamed her for being kidnapped and called her “the slave” and “the people-eater.” This severe lack of community support only exacerbated her fragile mental condition.

“She was a slut. She was a whore. She was high. She was drunk. She was in the streets. That’s what she gets. She shouldn’t have been [insert any excuse]. ” Whenever you hear someone say these things, whenever these words leave your mouth, know that these beliefs nurture the ambitions of abusers and murderers.

What she was, who she was, doesn’t negate her personhood. It didn’t negate her human right to live and be free.

There is a dispute over whether or not Gary Heidnik was sane while he was committing these unthinkable acts. His past medical records indicate that he may have been schizophrenic. But one thing is clear, Heidnik knew for certain where to find the perfect victims, the people that were would less likely to be protected or fought for. He chose the people that had already been used, abused and thrown away by society….poor, young, Black women.

That’s what really enabled this crime…a mass societal lack of care and he knew it.

I guess he wasn’t insane after all.


Learn more about this case:

Learn how to prevent events like this from happening:

Spread The Word. Share This Post!


IMG_0054-ZF-7906-35913-1-001-006Jessica Ann Mitchell is the founder of & To reach JAM, email her at Follow Jessica @TweetingJAM.

Follow OurLegaci at



23 thoughts on “Did Anybody Care?

  1. I can’t believe I’ve never heard of this story before. Thanks for putting this back in the spotlight. Why did it take so long for these women to get rescued? I’m just glad they were finally freed.

    1. Freed? Freeeeed you say??? My Aunt Deborah was used as a pawn by Jackie that is something the story doesn’t tell you my aunt is the one in the middle bottom. See the part that they left out was that Jackie told Heine of my aunts plan to free everybody so she can get in his good graces that’s how he end up killing my aunt and them two going to New Jersey to bury her that’s how she got away. I’m sorry but I hate when Society get things twisted up.

  2. In Lisa Lang’s feature in this one of the ladies commented that no one came looking for her and that none of them had been reported as missing so your comments about how society views and individual was echoed in her own perspective of the problem

    1. The Ling presentation was grossly inaccurate and based heavily on Jackie Askin’s opinions and impressions.
      In this news report from the time there is an interview with the mother of one of the girls where she not only talks about reporting her daughter missing but also of leading police right to Heidnik’s door.

  3. Too much of this is seen solely in the context of its extremity- so awful, an outlying occurrence, “we’ll never know why/how this happened”, “he was just a monster, can’t account for that”. All the while forgetting the particulars about to whom it literally happened. They also played a major role.

    Our conscience is speaking through Our Legaci in this piece.

  4. What is even more sad is their own communities reaction, further traumatizing (at least one of) the victims. In a similar (well publicized)case the victims were given amazing amounts of support after horrifying acts. Would be interesting to Analyse why the community response was so markedly different. Power to the girls for surviving

  5. We should be better than this. Not just devaluing the life of a prostitute or drug addict as if she were not human and therefore making her suffering some kind of abstraction. I mean that we deem it socially acceptable to blame poor people for being poor and to sweep the disenfranchised and marginalized members of our society into the shadows where the can be forgotten.

    Remember Gary Ridgway, the Green River Killer? Somehow I doubt it would have taken over 20 years to catch him of his victims had not been mostly poor black and hispanic prostitutes.


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s